- Strategic Customer Focus: Early-stage companies are advised to shift attention from rapid acquisition toward fostering deep loyalty and long-term advocacy within their initial client base.
- Collaborative Product Development: Engaging early customers in roadmap decisions, prototype feedback, and feature prioritization leverages their direct input to refine product utility.
- Intensive Service Investment: Tactics such as providing direct access to founders, dedicated engineering support for bug resolution, and personalized onboarding create high-touch experiences that differentiate new products.
- Mutual Brand Amplification: Capitalizing on opportunities like case studies allows the firm to gain social proof while providing clients with professional visibility and career advancement.
- Cultural Foundation Building: Although these unscalable practices do not persist indefinitely, they establish the organizational values and operational quality that inform long-term brand identity.
Playbooks
How to make your first customers raving fans
Proven tactics that turn early customers into lifelong advocates
[

](https://substack.com/@dpolitis)
David Politis
Apr 16, 2026
[

](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!liMT!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fb381b11b-fc8f-4665-b738-91ec96dec2bc_1200x627.png)
When you close your first customer, there’s this overwhelming sense of relief. You did it. You got someone to say yes. They’ve signed the contract, and they’re actually paying for something you built.
And then you immediately move on to finding the next customer.
I’ve seen this happen with almost every first-time founder I work with. You put so much energy into landing those first deals that once they close, you’re already thinking about how to get the next one. It feels like momentum, and when investors are pushing you to hit ARR milestones and customer count targets, it makes sense to think this way.
Plus, in those early days, you’re not really dealing with churn yet. Everyone is in the first few months of using the product or year one of their contract. But if you don’t invest in turning those first customers into raving fans, you’re not just risking churn down the road, you’re missing a massive upside opportunity.
I’m talking about going above and beyond, doing unscalable things to make your customers feel valued and like they’re part of your company, from day one.
Table of contents
Your first customers are the ones who help you build
The compound value of raving fans
Ask early customers what to build next
Assign a dedicated engineer to fix bugs immediately
Spend recurring 1:1 time with early customers
Hold their hand during implementation and onboarding
Amplify their personal brand
Go overboard with personalized swag
Ask for feedback on prototypes before building
Early customers are more like investors, not just buyers
Your early customers help you figure out what to build when you barely have a product. They’re the ones who will sit through bugs, missing features, and a clunky UI. They’ll give you feedback and forgive you when you make mistakes.
And if you do this right, your early customers will go to bat for you in several ways. They’ll be references for you (for other customers, investors, and partners), volunteer to participate in case studies and write reviews about you on sites like G2, and speak at conferences on behalf of your company.
These are the people who push you to add new features, they tell you what they’re seeing from competitors, and they become your eyes and ears in the market. They’re invested in your success in a way that customer number 500 never will be.
The compound value of raving fans
When you have that first set of customers who feel like they’ve been in the trenches with you, you get something most founders don’t realize they need until it’s too late: leeway to mess up.
Your product goes down for half a day? They stand by you. Renewal comes up, and the price increases 20%, 30%, or even 40%? They fight for the budget. A competitor reaches out with a cheaper alternative? They don’t take the call because you’ve already built trust and loyalty with them. Or even better, maybe they take the call to gather some intel, then share it with you.
This is the compound value. These relationships pay dividends for years.
That core group of early customers could be with you for 10 years, maybe more. Sometimes at the same company, often not. When they leave for their next role, you’re the first product they buy. They’ve already invested in you. They know the product works. They trust you and your team. So when they land at a new company and need to solve the same problem, they’re not evaluating five vendors; they’re going to you.
But they don’t stop there. They tell their colleagues and industry friends about you. They share your company on social media. They become word-of-mouth marketing engines for your brand.
If you do this right, these early customers will feel like they’re part of your story. They were there early with you, helping you build and being patient as you went through growing pains.
This is what’s on the line when you’re deciding whether to invest the time, energy, and money in making your first customers love you.
Here are seven ways to turn your first customers into raving fans.
Share
1. Ask early customers what to build next
You’ll hear tons of feature requests from early customers, and it will probably overwhelm you. Here’s how to figure out what to prioritize while also surprising and delighting them.
The key is letting your customers help you decide. Send a quick survey to all your current customers. “We’ve heard these 10 things over and over again. Which one do you think we should build next?” Make it clear that the feature that gets the most votes will be prioritized next.
Build whichever one gets the most votes. And this is the most important part: follow up with them and close the loop. When you ship the feature, email all of them and tell them it’s live. Tell them you built it because they voted for it, and thank them for pushing you to get it out.
It’s that simple, but you’ll be surprised how many companies fail to approach early product development this way. And when you close the loop, it establishes a level of trust and loyalty that can’t be matched.
Tip: Don’t put anything on this list that you’re not willing to build. This isn’t a fake democracy where you pretend to care about their input and then build whatever you want. You have to be ready to deliver.
2. Assign a dedicated engineer to fix bugs immediately
Every piece of software has bugs, and most software users expect them. This is especially true for new products. But what they don’t expect is for you to fix those bugs fast.
If you have someone dedicated to fixing bugs as soon as they come in, you create goodwill that’s hard to replicate any other way. Of course, many bugs can’t be resolved right away, but a lot can. Most companies don’t do this, and it’s an easy win for building trust and loyalty.
This doesn’t mean you need a full-time engineer dedicated to fixing bugs (but depending on your product, team size, number of customers, and the quality of your code, maybe you do). Having someone on call ready to jump in and resolve issues quickly is what matters. Maybe they even get on a call with the customer to recreate the bug and show they’re actively working on it.
Again, close the loop. Don’t just fix it silently and hope they notice. Tell them it’s done. That’s the whole play. Fix it fast, tell them you fixed it, and move on.
Tip: Have engineers on rotation in the support queue so customers can talk directly with the people who fix bugs. This creates a memorable experience for the customer and gives your engineers invaluable exposure to real user problems.
3. Spend recurring 1:1 time with early customers
As the CEO of a small startup doing very little in revenue, you might feel insignificant. You could go out of business tomorrow. Who cares about getting on a call with you, right?
Wrong. Your customers don’t get on calls with Zoom’s CEO, and they’re not talking to the CEO of Salesforce. When most of the products they use are from massive companies, having direct access to you (the CEO or founder, the person making product decisions) is a differentiation.
Your title matters, even if you feel like it doesn’t.
In the early days of BetterCloud, I was doing monthly hour-long meetings with our first customers. Then it moved to quarterly as we scaled, and it naturally became less frequent. But in those early days, that recurring time was critical.
These weren’t support calls. We talked about what we were building and why. We talked about what we were seeing in the market and what their peers (our other customers) were seeing. I’d share our roadmap and get their feedback. They’d tell me about their business priorities and where they were getting stuck.
All of this helps influence the roadmap, which is super important. But it also meant I could help them be more successful in their role.
I could tell them, “Other companies are approaching this problem this way,” or “Here’s what’s working for similar teams.” That kind of market intelligence is valuable for your product and for your customer relationships.
Tip: Make yourself accessible beyond those scheduled meetings. I’ve seen founders spin up shared Slack channels with clients where the entire engineering team can communicate directly with the customer. I’ve seen other CEOs give out their personal cell phone numbers.
4. Hold their hand during implementation and onboarding
Many customers, especially with an immature product, are going to struggle. Maybe the UI is bad. Or some product features are half-baked. Or critical functionality might be missing altogether, requiring manual workarounds.
This is normal for new products, but you can’t ignore those gaps. Your job is to make sure whatever problem they’re trying to solve with your product is actually achievable.
This is the forward-deployed engineer concept people talk about now. Sometimes it’s a consultant. Sometimes it’s a customer support person. The point is to hold the customer’s hand and provide whatever resources they need to be successful.
That might be helping them write custom integrations or building bespoke solutions for them on the fly. Or maybe it’s simply walking them through a workflow.
This doesn’t have to be you personally (although it might be). It could be your co-founder, CTO, or your first support hire. Whatever the case, someone needs to own making sure these customers are successful.
Tip: Don’t charge for implementation support. It’s too early at this stage. If these are your first customers, the ROI of them truly using your product and loving it outweighs any dollars you’d get from professional services or consulting. You want them in there, using it, seeing its value, and telling others about it.
5. Amplify their personal brand
This one is underrated. Many of the people you’re selling to (whether directors, managers, or individual contributors) have never had their personal brand out there in the world. They’ve never been featured in anything professionally. No one has ever asked them to do a case study, appear in a video, or talk publicly about their work.
So when you go to them and say, “We’d love to do a case study with you,” most founders frame it as a favor. “Would you be willing to help us out and lend your name to our company?”
Flip that around. Position it as, “We want to amplify you. You’re taking a unique approach here. You’re doing something forward-thinking that other people in your role should know about, and we want to feature that. We want to share it with other customers and potential customers.”
Do a case study, record a video, and post it on LinkedIn, tagging them. For a lot of people I’ve done this with, it’s the first time in their career that anyone has featured them or their work.
I had someone tell me once, “You did this. You put me out there. And I actually got a bunch of job offers because other people saw what I was doing at my company.”
You get a case study and social proof. They get career advancement and visibility. It’s not a favor, it’s a trade that benefits both of you.
Tip: Make it easy for them to say yes. Provide a brief on the key discussion points you want to include so they can come prepared, confident, and aligned on the narrative.
6. Go overboard with personalized swag
This one sounds stupid, but it works.
Most companies handle swag the same way: They get the cheapest hoodies, slap their logo on them, and send them out. The customer gets it, says “thanks,” and it sits in a drawer forever next to all the other swag they’ve collected.
Do the opposite, get creative. Send them something that makes them feel special. Think limited-edition, personalized, and high-quality swag like a Timbuk2 backpack or Yeti Tumbler. It should be something they value and that they can tell you put serious thought into.
When we were a 10-person company, we printed 60 hoodies. We sent 50 of them to our first 50 customers and kept 10 for our employees. That’s it. Those were the only people who had that hoodie, and we told them that.
“Only the first 50 customers and our 10 employees have this hoodie. Thank you for being a part of this with us.”
We also took the time to write real thank-you cards and had everyone at the company sign them. Does this take time and money? Yea. But it’s about thoughtfulness.
I even sent swag to an entire IT leader once so they could distribute it to their entire team. They were so excited about it that they posted photos on social media wearing our gear. Years would pass, and customers would show up at our booth at conferences wearing the hoodie with our original logo, and they were so proud to show it off. You can’t buy that kind of organic visibility.
Tip: Spend more than you feel comfortable with. Get creative with it, and do something unexpected. You don’t always need to do this, but in the early days, this is a great way to stand out, make an impact, and be memorable.
7. Ask for feedback on prototypes before building
Let’s say a customer requests a feature in one of those monthly calls. Great. You agree it makes sense to build, and you add it to the roadmap.
But there are hundreds of different ways you could build that feature. Instead of just going off and building based on your best guess, interview them, and then show them a clickable prototype. Have other potential users click through the prototype and get their feedback and do this before you write a single line of code.
This does two things:
First, you get actual product insights. You find out whether your approach solves their problem or if you’re missing something. You catch issues before they become expensive rebuilds or lead to disappointed customers.
Second, they feel valued and involved. They’re not just requesting features and hoping you build them correctly. They’re actively shaping how those features work. That reinforces the idea that they’re part of building this product with you.
It’s collaborative instead of transactional, and that difference matters.
These things aren’t scalable, and that’s okay
You can’t do monthly CEO calls with 1,000 customers. You can’t send personalized swag to every user. You can’t have a dedicated engineer fixing bugs for every single person who reports one.
But you don’t have to do these things forever. You have to do them now, in the early days.
What you’re really building here isn’t just happy customers. You’re building your company’s DNA and culture. You’re establishing how you treat people, how you think about customer relationships, and what you’re willing to invest in to make people feel valued.
That becomes embedded in who you are as you grow. It sets the standard for how your team operates in the long term. And in markets with 100 copycats and new competitors spinning up faster than ever, this is how you stand apart.
Your competitors can copy your features, and they can undercut your pricing, but they can’t replicate the relationships you built when you were small enough to treat every customer like they were part of your team.
Key takeaways
Your first 10 customers are worth exponentially more than customer #500 because they give you momentum and help you build.
Raving fans give you references for customers and investors, market intelligence from competitors, and leeway to mess up when your product goes down or prices increase.
The tactics that create raving fans aren’t scalable, but it builds company DNA and culture that can last forever, differentiating you from the competition.
Not all early customers will become raving fans, but you’ll create a nucleus you can mobilize, leverage, and trust for years.
Share
FAQs
How many customers should I treat this way? Start with your first 10. After that, you need to start thinking about scale, but the culture you build doing those things should persist as you grow.
What if I can’t afford to give away free implementation help? The ROI from these customers who actually use and love your product far exceeds any service revenue. This is an investment in building advocates, references, and long-term customers who will buy from you again when they join a new company.
When should I stop doing monthly CEO 1:1s? Let growth dictate the transition, no arbitrary timelines. I went from monthly to quarterly as we scaled, then eventually phased them out at a larger scale. But in the early days, that recurring time is critical.
Isn’t this just good customer success? Yes, but it’s beyond that. You’re treating your first customers like employees when it comes to access, attention, and investment. Standard customer success doesn’t typically involve the CEO doing monthly calls. These tactics are deliberately excessive and not scalable.
Subscribe to Not Another CEO
Launched a year ago
#1 place for CEOs to grow themselves and their companies
By subscribing, you agree Substack's Terms of Use, and acknowledge its Information Collection Notice and Privacy Policy.
[

](https://substack.com/profile/27506701-john)[

](https://substack.com/profile/480376909-heavy-days)[

](https://substack.com/profile/930268-sumeet-shah)[

](https://substack.com/profile/259370574-david-politis)
102 Likes
Discussion about this post
How to conduct a board meeting
Stop dreading your board meetings and start using them as the strategic tool they’re meant to be
Feb 19 • David Politis

March 2026 roundup
New masterclasses, founder/CEO coffee & co-working, networking dinners, and more
Mar 5 • Nicholas Freund

April 2026 roundup
A look at everything Not Another CEO has planned for April: master classes, coworking, and poker nights. Plus, a Webby Award nomination!
Apr 2 • Nicholas Freund

Ready for more?